[Privacy triage] Over to the team behind the V8 optimizer.

I can't reproduce this in Canary 131.0.6734.0, however we did land a bugfix for a regression that may have been linked to this in https://crbug.com/364820109, which didn't land in Canary until 131.0.6724. Are you sure this reproduced in .6726?

I still can reproduce it in Chrome Canary 131.0.6734.0, not always but most of the time.

That's very puzzling - the culprit change wasn't in M129.

Does this happen when they are loaded from other places like the omnibox?

It happens only if I click on the bookmark on the bookmarks bar. If I open it directly from address bar (omnibox) or open it from a folder from bookmarks bar, then it doesn't happen.

Thank you for providing more feedback. Adding the requester to the CC list.

I cannot duplicate it on Mac. There must be something on Windows and Linux that's different.

I reproduced this in 131.0.6737.0 on Linux. The bookmark bar thing is a red herring - you can actually reproduce it by just loading enough separate YouTube tabs. Once you open enough tabs (generally 3-4), the renderer crashes:

[1819714:1:0924/150358.404360:FATAL:render_frame_impl.cc(2305)] Check failed: !in_frame_tree_. 
#0 0x55d72500e316 base::debug::CollectStackTrace() [../../base/debug/stack_trace_posix.cc:1044:7]
#1 0x55d724fe6e64 base::debug::StackTrace::StackTrace() [../../base/debug/stack_trace.cc:245:20]
#2 0x55d724e2a5f5 logging::LogMessage::Flush() [../../base/logging.cc:739:29]
#3 0x55d724e2a46a logging::LogMessage::~LogMessage() [../../base/logging.cc:727:3]
#4 0x55d724dfc1f1 logging::(anonymous namespace)::CheckLogMessage::~CheckLogMessage() [../../base/check.cc:171:3]
#5 0x55d724dfc284 logging::(anonymous namespace)::CheckLogMessage::~CheckLogMessage() [../../base/check.cc:166:31]
#6 0x55d724dfbea0 logging::CheckError::~CheckError() [../../third_party/libc++/src/include/__memory/unique_ptr.h:69:5]
#7 0x55d7321ca68d content::RenderFrameImpl::Delete() [../../content/renderer/render_frame_impl.cc:2305:7]
#8 0x55d71b6b03fe content::mojom::FrameStubDispatch::Accept() [gen/content/common/frame.mojom.cc:2839:13]
#9 0x55d724dad8a5 mojo::InterfaceEndpointClient::HandleValidatedMessage() [../../mojo/public/cpp/bindings/lib/interface_endpoint_client.cc:1051:54]
#10 0x55d724dc0021 mojo::MessageDispatcher::Accept() [../../mojo/public/cpp/bindings/lib/message_dispatcher.cc:43:19]
#11 0x55d724db0eb5 mojo::InterfaceEndpointClient::HandleIncomingMessage() [../../mojo/public/cpp/bindings/lib/interface_endpoint_client.cc:724:20]
#12 0x55d72649b858 IPC::ChannelAssociatedGroupController::AcceptOnEndpointThread() [../../ipc/ipc_mojo_bootstrap.cc:1215:24]
#13 0x55d72649cadb base::internal::Invoker<>::RunOnce() [../../base/functional/bind_internal.h:738:12]
#14 0x55d7187011a8 base::OnceCallback<>::Run() [../../base/functional/callback.h:156:12]
#15 0x55d724efee8e base::TaskAnnotator::RunTaskImpl() [../../base/task/common/task_annotator.cc:202:34]
#16 0x55d724f531f0 base::sequence_manager::internal::ThreadControllerWithMessagePumpImpl::DoWorkImpl() [../../base/task/common/task_annotator.h:90:5]
#17 0x55d724f5224c base::sequence_manager::internal::ThreadControllerWithMessagePumpImpl::DoWork() [../../base/task/sequence_manager/thread_controller_with_message_pump_impl.cc:332:40]
#18 0x55d724f53e0b base::sequence_manager::internal::ThreadControllerWithMessagePumpImpl::DoWork()
#19 0x55d724e40fc2 base::MessagePumpDefault::Run() [../../base/message_loop/message_pump_default.cc:40:55]
#20 0x55d724f54a12 base::sequence_manager::internal::ThreadControllerWithMessagePumpImpl::Run() [../../base/task/sequence_manager/thread_controller_with_message_pump_impl.cc:640:12]
#21 0x55d724eb081c base::RunLoop::Run() [../../base/run_loop.cc:133:14]
#22 0x55d73235b176 content::RendererMain() [../../content/renderer/renderer_main.cc:361:16]
#23 0x55d723394098 content::RunZygote() [../../content/app/content_main_runner_impl.cc:700:14]
#24 0x55d7233956b6 content::RunOtherNamedProcessTypeMain() [../../content/app/content_main_runner_impl.cc:804:12]
#25 0x55d723397f90 content::ContentMainRunnerImpl::Run() [../../content/app/content_main_runner_impl.cc:1164:10]
#26 0x55d723392dac content::RunContentProcess() [../../content/app/content_main.cc:356:36]
#27 0x55d72339315b content::ContentMain() [../../content/app/content_main.cc:369:10]
#28 0x55d718390116 ChromeMain [../../chrome/app/chrome_main.cc:231:12]
#29 0x7f0fc9843b8a (/usr/lib/x86_64-linux-gnu/libc.so.6+0x27b89)
#30 0x7f0fc9843c45 __libc_start_main
#31 0x55d71837602a _start
Task trace:
#0 0x55d72649012c IPC::ChannelAssociatedGroupController::Accept() [../../ipc/ipc_mojo_bootstrap.cc:1154:13]
Crash keys:
  "max_scheduler_idle_tasks" = "0"
  "max_idle_tasks" = "0"
  "subresource_url" = "https://www.youtube.com/s/search/audio/success.mp3"
  "view-count" = "2"
  "loaded-origin-0" = "https://www.youtube.com"
  "web-frame-count" = "4"
  "gpu-gl-renderer" = "ANGLE (Google, Vulkan 1.3.0 (SwiftShader Device (Subzero) (0x0000C0DE)), SwiftShader driver-5.0.0)"
  "gpu-gl-vendor" = "Google Inc. (Google)"
  "gpu-generation-intel" = "0"
  "gpu-vsver" = "1.00"
  "gpu-psver" = "1.00"
  "gpu-driver" = "5.0.0"
  "gpu_count" = "0"
  "gpu-devid" = "0xffff"
  "gpu-venid" = "0xffff"
  "renderer_foreground" = "false"
  "v8_ro_space_firstpage_address" = "0x7e0700000000"
  "v8_isolate_address" = "0x315400404000"
  "variations" = "e61eae14-3f4a17df,e32097a3-3f4a17df,b13ca3d9-84f6cff8,f2b6a878-3f4a17df,be9ac099-f9095748,2468d6e5-3f4a17df,f5a1eb9a-3f4a17df,886fd002-3f4a17df,f69863c5-3f4a17df,50eef52b-3f4a17df,bb88d3f2-3f4a17df,db0f7f8d-3f4a17df,d0d3d7ff-3f4a17df,f3daed27-3f4a17df,768eeee-5dd67d03,72baad2d-3f4a17df,ff6056ba-3f4a17df,48a8d64c-3f4a17df,ac59e11a-3f4a17df,b1de23e3-3f2a3d9,2288e0d7-3f4a17df,836f1ad3-3f4a17df,d6284ba0-9610fd4e,47a0a3b2-3f4a17df,b334488c-3f4a17df,3d908067-3f4a17df,dc88470b-339f19b3,2c561bd6-3f4a17df,97063883-1f820d08,d4754f61-3f4a17df,13427e22-3f4a17df,af00e384-3f4a17df,df41299a-3f4a17df,4d3e0af4-3f4a17df,314a19c6-3f4a17df,6b7d4090-3f4a17df,601dc969-3f4a17df,ae727645-d13781e7,90dda23e-3f4a17df,b7ed4ad2-3f4a17df,d3aecf6a-3f4a17df,f1cbb679-3d47f4f4,2509a2d9-3f4a17df,37d8b29f-e83452ae,26016f9f-4df4f25e,5eb9e4fc-3f4a17df,4d936449-fd549ada,2fe27454-cd4a4a24,cad2b12b-8ef57898,57d6085b-3f4a17df,3d828cea-e3f1ce85,6d2935ee-3f4a17df,17a43872-3f4a17df,a88cddf3-3f4a17df,1ffefb1a-3f4a17df,17f5c3f5-3f4a17df,f45c108d-65bced95,f7d06457-e9d42fcd,bcb58f65-3f4a17df,d512da3a-513c429d,bf9ed750-d9924ac7,e3449d65-3f4a17df,83492eae-3f4a17df,c27db683-f337689b,999e8980-6ec7edcb,8a12c4c0-71393850,945bfd49-8ec20be3,bdfa447c-3f4a17df,86bc59c9-3f4a17df,d7fffc22-3f4a17df,6b1f3ab8-d16f1562,46d7c84e-3f4a17df,3bcba8c9-d6781875,adfbede8-ad8ed5ef,5133eb43-307b98b1,76117bda-3f4a17df,f314f5b9-35ef4d3e,82ada734-df5071b7,6e4a21fe-efc28565,43bba9d8-d1b30714,78634d5f-2ba5dc1c,4749874c-455e925b,820f17d2-e484eeec,40debc11-3f4a17df,12733ec4-3f4a17df,4ffe7de9-3f4a17df,206d80d-3f4a17df,44666d99-3d47f4f4,bc8fe6fd-3f4a17df,db96cb03-3f4a17df,55ba4cfa-3f4a17df,9c4e9263-f2280ca0,5c4d440e-58c8ac88,fd051c38-3f4a17df,44d0ae84-3f4a17df,a98def31-2a5a8f5d,ddb8ff70-3f4a17df,7627ad7c-3f4a17df,3864eb98-3d47f4f4,64fc6f03-f716500,d625ae6a-5570cbfd,7dcaa2cd-3f4a17df,f3d990c-69465896,18324944-3f4a17df,24e1e5d7-3f4a17df,8c6d6f42-3f4a17df,b374b540-b374b540,27b4de92-3f4a17df,d446ca5c-3f4a17df,a83aa76f-3f4a17df,b652e8cd-3f4a17df,f8411335-f8411335,d7ce3099-3f4a17df,caf19648-369d3741,bd6dd170-96cd1f5b,669a7db8-3f4a17df,350559e5-3f4a17df,a05c89eb-67c903d4,91cba98-b3b3bb94,d97f772b-c4b8b19c,87684b46-82506638,4620a8f0-3f4a17df,c75c6bbe-3f4a17df,e5c8270a-3f4a17df,ef3132a9-3f4a17df,7a74f189-d34b6670,3042ad4b-ad2fa222,ab57163a-3f4a17df,ae1581ef-35f6ea04,c0876afc-3f4a17df,3c978b59-3f4a17df,1d865dc8-3b8fb192,255aa854-6e4db4c1,194d8898-3f4a17df,ece98647-3f4a17df,5c835c76-3f4a17df,b654e8a3-3f4a17df,a3c3aad0-3f4a17df,31a21008-fdca1981,9982045c-3f4a17df,1a04f685-e44403bb,2e7369a1-4aceb943,f43fe77d-3f4a17df,95a095bd-3f4a17df,96d006a-c3a49e71,f6264095-c3f8eab0,b3a4e30a-3f4a17df,f42905ff-3f4a17df,71c14987-3f4a17df,2faf225b-3f4a17df,8fdf0376-3f4a17df,36d5ee52-3f4a17df,7d05570e-76a4e021,864a51e5-aa32be6,1f70f502-3f4a17df,f992ad01-3f4a17df,e9844d40-3f4a17df,ad9b71e2-a1d7110,d2aa7cc-3f4a17df,45b76973-6f345330,34e11aee-9a6e5472,3dbad317-3f4a17df,cad46b80-3f4a17df,8bccc03b-3f4a17df,c0981e85-ae90dc34,57e6ff6b-3f4a17df,7aed4fe4-3f4a17df,b7ff085-3d47f4f4,d29b37b7-3f4a17df,cd9c6915-34a254ad,e6ed801e-cf4f6ead,fc9ceed7-ee2a48b4,5a474f9e-3f4a17df,c823d1e9-3d47f4f4,cbd17ba8-eeadba7f,b86bee04-3f4a17df,9e5c75f1-30e1b12b,447b84ff-3f4a17df,725a78a7-ac3faf8,4d625646-3f4a17df,35290cf-ce50784e,24b6a44d-1623a499,62366563-3f4a17df,86328c20-5c112879,e5938e6b-3f4a17df,dcceede7-908383eb,2394f90f-ecc8f8cf,d5f746a4-39aaf314,ad44b293-66e8dc66,cb85e943-3f4a17df,56aa5797-e5fec5a6,55594d64-65bced95,265c01cc-3f4a17df,e2d38844-3f4a17df,ca5a2953-ff983c32,314a184e-3f4a17df,da493d3c-3f4a17df,3e45686e-d1bf3faa,72bafd3e-cdb4c186,f659c5ca-3f4a17df,f3ed486d-3f4a17df,f503a768-3f4a17df,9dea5087-3f4a17df,b3c54bb3-88fcaf7d,136ff6f9-f23d1dea,4076100b-3f4a17df,68fef0c-3f4a17df,aa21b99b-3f4a17df,6ad21bf6-727a1257,c892bdaf-4daf39ea,b50b4b1f-93205ab,10713630-3f4a17df,bc2567e7-3f4a17df,b76b514f-3f4a17df,741e95d4-3f4a17df,8a0ecb67-3f4a17df,d3566fbd-c6f74b94,f24e8f06-3f4a17df,147e9ecd-3f4a17df,b33374a1-3f4a17df,2ad820b5-7eba58d7,e5354680-89f76c70,bb73ab6c-24afcbc6,7a810513-3f4a17df,afdb4613-3f4a17df,7769705-bd377632,5abe5347-3f4a17df,349863a7-3f4a17df,35a386c3-3f4a17df,77b7ea96-9a159164,bff0815b-3f4a17df,7fb629a1-60fdb59,45a2f2f-f9e1b5a8,d9ab447-b187d1bd,c984ae3d-65bced95,47be28a0-174c3153,fc0fca39-3f4a17df,28410024-3f4a17df,186d6e2c-36c0e608,c65234ba-3f4a17df,de7bb458-3f4a17df,66b7a83f-3f4a17df,137f6fe-3f4a17df,ecd9add5-3f4a17df,4ea303a6-3f4a17df,79a319d6-3f4a17df,4190c9c9-5cabb8a4,79662520-3f4a17df,258151b3-3f4a17df,7c0d937f-3f4a17df,5eb745a8-3f4a17df,aa540f4f-3f4a17df,30cf4980-61673e6,9850104b-395bafa,19e446cd-3f4a17df,f3b6291d-128494d0,f5181214-3f4a17df,68837d01-3f4a17df,c8612216-3f4a17df,bc8524f8-3f4a17df,d3897495-3f4a17df,5f30b51a-f38d1999,e111950-5b3f7a59,f112d133-3f4a17df,f9be514e-3f4a17df,9a564e2a-3f4a17df,acc8bc10-3f4a17df,d2094477-3f4a17df,39bb70f9-3f4a17df,583702ee-3f4a17df,108bcc75-3f4a17df,2bac9a6a-3f4a17df,180abb82-3f4a17df,bee81df6-3f4a17df,f73677d0-3f4a17df,d990c4ac-3f4a17df,1918000d-af12514f,5c7c8339-3f4a17df,23226e84-65aafa13,615f375c-36db5131,3797f84b-3f4a17df,d0083347-bd024091,af07f8be-a39fdf08,ef4764d7-88fcaf7d,ccc5f0aa-3f4a17df,c26ea5ae-e3cbd707,613081e8-3f4a17df,c49d2b35-3f4a17df,377002b7-3f4a17df,935eb749-7a935877,1fce7d57-3f4a17df,585aa9da-3f4a17df,e8c68789-49a20295,4b266bfd-3f4a17df,b0f15b33-b0f15b33,152ed874-3f4a17df,b45d023c-5fae3666,a8045d2e-aaac510a,ab8cfc0f-91c810ef,3fc87288-3f4a17df,1130dae-12829759,dd037d0e-3f4a17df,ad18a4fe-56aa6be3,49ad328f-3f4a17df,b56876e4-a6ad8aed,5f082a30-3f4a17df,ad4acdda-3f4a17df,90860314-5ab828e2,8ab62623-3f4a17df,7ec047c2-3f4a17df,ade3efeb-e1cc0f14,f48c01d3-6eb2bd2b,97ef3704-3f4a17df,b1ceb06f-3f4a17df,97c42540-3f4a17df,d91dc415-3f4a17df,1f173648-3f4a17df,db59f83a-3f4a17df,b1a0623-3f4a17df,c1e0d32e-3f4a17df,bea4a9c2-ef4c90a8,b6cdf4d5-3f4a17df,db55e85b-ecb6e1a6,3b96a1d-3f4a17df,d04818be-3f4a17df,cef95416-b1f74a2,11c437b-cc0e2011,bdcaab27-3f4a17df,5910121-3f4a17df,f9a6f6e9-3f4a17df,595f5eb0-f23d1dea,4a86715e-3f4a17df,2fed65b6-3f4a17df,ff1dade5-190c81ea,2e8b9b7-3f4a17df,b0ebc2b4-3f4a17df,54412203-573b100b,e0e211ad-e0e211ad,762e8080-cda89520,8499d920-3f4a17df,fd55a9a4-3f4a17df,8d7344de-61d56a05,b53f3ef9-3f4a17df,"
  "num-experiments" = "371"
  "reentry_guard_tls_slot" = "unused"
  "switch-16" = "--variations-seed-version"
  "switch-15" = "--field-trial-handle=3,i,15870577115101254321,138287877843431382"
  "switch-14" = "--metrics-shmem-handle=4,i,5496838197604984533,13682052394719081"
  "switch-13" = "--shared-files=v8_context_snapshot_data:100"
  "switch-12" = "--launch-time-ticks=88390686274"
  "switch-11" = "--time-ticks-at-unix-epoch=-1727101828941020"
  "switch-10" = "--renderer-client-id=18"
  "switch-9" = "--enable-main-frame-before-activation"
  "switch-8" = "--num-raster-threads=4"
  "switch-7" = "--js-flags=--disable-optimizing-compilers"
  "switch-6" = "--lang=en-US"
  "switch-5" = "--disable-gpu-compositing"
  "osarch" = "x86_64"
  "pid" = "1"
  "ptype" = "renderer"
  "switch-4" = "--change-stack-guard-on-fork=enable"
  "switch-3" = "--user-data-dir=/tmp/udd0"
  "switch-2" = "--enable-crash-reporter=,"
  "switch-1" = "--crashpad-handler-pid=1819128"
  "num-switches" = "18"

Gracias You guys are much more than a blessing to the society in as much as you guys got all it takes to execute all sectors with my little knowledge here I put all here

Affected Versions: Canary: 131.0.6726.0 Dev: 130.0.6710.0 Beta: 130.0.6723.6 Stable: 129.0.6668.59 Operating Systems: Windows 10, Linux Debian, Mac 14.6.1 Description: When the “Don’t allow sites to use the V8 optimizer” option is enabled, some websites (e.g., YouTube, X) do not load if opened from the bookmarks bar. First Seen: M122 (122.0.6253.0) Current Status: Marked as Untriaged, removed from ‘Unconfirmed’ hotlist. Steps to Reproduce: Enable the “Don’t allow sites to use the V8 optimizer” option. Open a website like YouTube or X from the bookmarks bar. Observe that the website does not load. Notes: The issue is reproducible on multiple operating systems. The “Manage V8 security” option has been available since M122. Request: Further investigation by the respective team to address this issue.